The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders 2023 Movie Review

Step into the world of a sinister serial killer as Netflix brings forth “The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders,” a riveting documentary that sheds light on a haunting era of heinous crimes against older women. From 1998 to 2006, Mexico City was gripped by fear as a series of murders left families shattered and authorities baffled. Directed by María Jose Cuevas, the docufilm takes viewers on a journey of investigation, unraveling the harrowing story of a relentless killer and the chilling impact on the victims’ families.

At the heart of the documentary lies the exploration of a disturbing mystery. As the killings continue, the police grapple with the killer’s identity, initially believing it to be a man, then a woman, and even a transgender person. The fear-stricken older women of Mexico lived in constant trepidation, while the police tried their best to make sense of the horrifying crimes. Despite arrests, the murders persist, leaving the city in terror.

The gripping narrative meticulously follows the investigation, providing viewers with insights into the perplexing case. The pressure on the police force intensifies as the murders continue relentlessly. The documentary delves into the many facets of the investigation, from erroneous arrests to the arrest of the real culprit, and raises important questions about the handling of the case.

In the last segment of the film, we finally come face to face with the real serial killer—Juana Barraza, a former wrestler who called herself “The Lady of Silence.” As the documentary unravels Juana’s troubled past, viewers are given a glimpse into the traumatic events that shaped her dark path. We witness how the woman behind the murders became an unlikely celebrity, with people dressing up like her and even creating songs and sketches in her name. The docufilm confronts the sensationalization of her crimes, drawing attention to the pain it caused the victims’ families.

María Jose Cuevas effectively presents the gravity of the crime and its impact through interviews, photos, old footage, and performative scenes. However, the use of over-dramatic transition effects and loud background music sometimes detracts from the seriousness of the case.

Overall, “The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders” is a gripping documentary for true-crime enthusiasts. It provides valuable insights into the investigation, while also leaving several unanswered questions to ponder. The film ensures that the focus remains on the victims, avoiding any glorification of the killer. As we delve into the chilling tale of Mexico’s first female serial killer, we are reminded of the haunting mysteries that still surround the case.

With its haunting storytelling and impactful portrayal of the victims’ stories, “The Lady of Silence: The Mataviejitas Murders” is a must-watch documentary that lingers in the mind long after the credits roll.